Youth Criminal Charges in Toronto: A Parent’s Guide to the YCJA Over the Winter Break

With schools closed for the winter break, young people across Toronto spend more time at malls, transit stations, house parties and online, often with less adult supervision than usual. For a family, the first sign of trouble can be a phone call from a police division saying a son or daughter has been arrested, questioned or handed a document with a court date. Few parents know that a separate federal law governs what happens next.

That law is the Youth Criminal Justice Act, usually shortened to the YCJA. It sets different rules for police questioning, diversion, court, publicity and records than the ones that apply to adults. What follows is general information about how the Act works in Ontario, not legal advice for a specific case.

Who the Youth Criminal Justice Act Covers in Toronto

The Act applies to a young person who was at least 12 years old but under 18 at the time of the alleged offence. Age at the time of the incident is what counts, so a person who turns 18 before the case reaches court still proceeds under the youth system. Children under 12 cannot be convicted of a criminal offence at all, because section 13 of the Criminal Code sets that minimum age.

The Act’s principles call for a youth justice system that is separate from the adult one and based on the diminished moral blameworthiness of young people. It emphasizes rehabilitation and reintegration, fair and proportionate accountability, and enhanced procedural protection, including privacy. Those principles shape decisions from the first police contact to sentencing.

Police Questioning of Young People in Toronto: The Section 146 Rules

Section 146 of the YCJA goes well beyond the rules that govern adult interviews. A statement a young person makes to police on arrest or detention, or when police have reasonable grounds to believe the youth committed an offence, is not admissible unless it was voluntary and the officer first explained, in language suited to the young person’s age and understanding, that there is no obligation to make a statement and that anything said may be used as evidence.

The officer must also explain the right to consult a lawyer and a parent, or another appropriate adult if no parent is available, and to make any statement in that person’s presence. A youth can waive these rights, but the waiver must be recorded on video or audio, or put in writing and signed. Spontaneous remarks made before police have a chance to give these explanations are treated differently, which is one reason the details of an arrest matter.

Section 26 requires police to notify a parent when a young person is arrested and held in custody, and also when a youth is released with an appearance notice, summons or undertaking. Parents who receive that notice can help the young person contact a lawyer before any interview. Under section 25, a young person has the right to retain and instruct a lawyer without delay at every stage of the process.

Extrajudicial Measures and Youth Diversion in Toronto

Before starting a prosecution, section 6 requires a police officer to consider whether it would be enough to take no further action, give a warning, administer a caution where a caution program exists, or refer the young person, with consent, to a community program. Section 4 adds that these extrajudicial measures are presumed adequate where the youth is accused of a non-violent offence and has never been found guilty of an offence. A first-time, non-violent allegation such as minor mischief is the kind of situation these provisions were written for.

Where those options are not adequate, an extrajudicial sanction under section 10 may be considered. Sanctions are more formal programs, and they come with conditions. The young person must be informed of the sanction, be advised of the right to a lawyer with a reasonable chance to consult one, freely consent, and accept responsibility for the act. The Crown must also be satisfied there is enough evidence to prosecute. Because accepting responsibility is part of the arrangement, legal advice before agreeing is especially valuable.

Youth Court at the Toronto Courthouse: Bail and Publication Bans

If a charge proceeds, the case is heard in youth court, which in Toronto sits at the Toronto Courthouse at 10 Armoury Street. The rules on pre-trial detention are narrower for young people than for adults. Under section 29, a judge or justice can order detention only in limited circumstances, generally where the charge is a serious offence or there is a history showing a pattern of outstanding charges or findings of guilt. Section 28.1 forbids using custody as a substitute for child protection, mental health or other social measures.

Section 31 also allows a youth who would otherwise be detained to be placed in the care of a responsible person, often a parent or relative, who agrees to supervise. Privacy is another major difference. Section 110 prohibits publishing the name of a young person, or any information that would identify them as someone dealt with under the Act, subject to narrow exceptions, chiefly where an adult sentence is imposed. The ban binds any person, not only news outlets, so a public social media post can breach it.

Youth Records in Ontario: How Long Access Lasts

Section 119 sets access periods, after which the record generally can no longer be accessed under the Act. The period ends two months after a charge is withdrawn or dismissed, two years after a young person consents to an extrajudicial sanction, one year after an absolute discharge, three years after a conditional discharge, three years after a youth sentence for a summary offence is completed, and five years after a youth sentence for an indictable offence is completed.

A new finding of guilt during an access period can extend it, and an adult conviction during certain access periods can cause the youth record to be treated like an adult record. Because these rules touch school, employment and travel plans, families often want guidance early. A youth criminal lawyer in Toronto can explain how the YCJA applies to a particular situation, whether diversion is realistic, and how to protect a young person’s privacy while the case runs its course.

[adinserter block="6"]


Sharing is Caring

ID); // If the post has no category, return if (!$categories) { return; } // Get the first category ID $category_id = $categories[0]; // Query for related posts in the same category $related_args = array( 'category__in' => array($category_id), 'post__not_in' => array($post->ID), 'posts_per_page' => 6, // Change this to the number of related posts you want to show 'orderby' => 'rand', // Change this to how you want to order the related posts ); $related_query = new WP_Query($related_args); // If there are no related posts, return if (!$related_query->have_posts()) { return; } // Output the related posts $output = ''; // Restore the original post data wp_reset_postdata(); // Output the related posts echo $output; } ?>
'; if ( $categories_list ) { echo ' Category:' . $categories_list . ''; } if ( $tags_list ) { echo ' Tags:' . $tags_list . ''; } echo ''; } } ?>

Leave a Comment